Sometimes you have to settle for what's available, not what's best, because otherwise you won't get anything at all.
That's the basic argument in favor of giving vast deregulatory freedom to some of America's telecommunications giants. Unless they can control who has access to their lines and at what price, say the cable and regional phone companies, they won't deploy the high-speed data access that the nation wants and needs.
In a move as craven as any we've seen lately, the technology industry seems to have signed onto this corporate extortion. Since broadband deployment is so crucial to the future of the tech companies, they're willing to jump into bed with anyone who'll make it happen sooner than later -- and the heck with the public interest.
And despite opposition from telecom competitors who fear being frozen out and do-gooders who understand the consequences, official Washington is leaning toward decisions that could make today's media concentration seem modest.
I say we should hold out for what's best, not what's expedient.
What's best? We could embark on a crash program, funded by taxpayers, to bring broadband to every home and business in America. Maybe it should be a build-out of networks using fiber and wireless technologies. Maybe it should be subsidies that allow end users to buy what they want, spurring industry innovation along the way.
This is a national security issue, if we understand it correctly. Broadband everywhere isn't just about vast new economic opportunities. By decentralizing the workforce, we are increasing our collective safety, too.
The danger of letting the telecom monopolists control the information that moves on their lines should be equally obvious. In an Information Age, giving such power to businesses with a history of abusing it seems bizarre.
At the very least, we must have laws -- and yes, that means hard-nosed regulation and enforcement -- ensuring that the cable and phone companies cannot discriminate against any content. For example, SBC Communications, which has a business partnership with Yahoo to provide DSL service, shouldn't be allowed to give customers slower access, or no access at all, to another portal site.
What would we lose by calling the telecom giants' bluff? Maybe a couple of years of rapid broadband deployment, though what they're deploying now -- DSL and cable modem connections -- runs at such a slow speed that it can only be called broadband if you stretch the definition. In South Korea and other places where deployment is going strong, speeds are much faster and prices much lower.
There's another party at this table, by the way. Local governments can and should be building their own fiber networks, as some already have done. Unsurprisingly, the phone companies have been lobbying state legislatures to forbid this practice. We need a federal law that explicitly allows municipalities to bypass the monopolists.
informant38
-
...But of these sophisms and elenchs of merchandise I skill not...
Milton, Areopagitica
Except he had found the
standing sea-rock that even this last
Temptation breaks on; quieter than death but lovelier; peace
that quiets the desire even of praising it.
Jeffers, Meditation On Saviors
-
4.11.02
Blog Archive
-
▼
2002
(2976)
-
▼
November
(320)
- intent is bunk!
- The gods do this in shame of cowardice: Caesar sho...
- A witness told rangers the shark approached Casey ...
- "I remember thinking I just want more. This isn't ...
- The final toll of the General Slocum fire has neve...
- The granddaughter of Mahatma Gandhi, Ela Gandhi, j...
- {what gets lost, what they trained us to miss, is ...
- reed man
- russetly
- Interface to the Future A version of real-time de...
- This brings the suicide rate closer to 0.68 suicid...
- "So, Ivan Ubiquovich, congratulations on surviving...
- OUT THERE, in happy family homes, in the offices o...
- Appropriately, Kissinger is a man on the run for h...
- "Others at a higher level of the fruit picking ind...
- The latest audiotape statement attributed to Osama...
- Mahfood had no idea how to react to the prisoners,...
- Ongoing Efforts In the Cultivation of Worthy Think...
- lovable hero_____________"It is at such a time and...
- Although the others managed to drive the lizard ba...
- the cynicism of the decision and the gross insult ...
- Many people think that Chinese government's attitu...
- The Eugene City Council passed a resolution Monday...
- In LQG, reality is built of loops that interact an...
- full color led flashlight
- sad optimism of an ant farmthe wide-open mind of a...
- {calm unbiased summing up of the history of Zionis...
- 100 quotes from Shakespeare
- when police officers swooped in on Mr. Sirven last...
- it's always High Noon somewhere
- Q. What's an "infix"? A. A word placed within ano...
- Studies thus far have neither shown nor ruled out ...
- Attorneys for the Bush Administration asked a fede...
- oreofuchi for ambassador
- From his prison cell in the Tower of London, a Fre...
- By the time the dust kicked up in that meeting had...
- One of Canada's feeble, American-neocon wannabes, ...
- Isabel Letelier learned more about torture than sh...
- Ducros was at the centre of a storm since last Thu...
- "Nearly every state is in fiscal crisis," the gove...
- {virtually every 'artist' listed in this gallery h...
- Ms Nigot killed herself last Tuesday, two weeks af...
- A secret population of orang-utans has been discov...
- Stuck in the Basque country in the eighties with n...
- Concoctions included the huMouse, a mixture of man...
- The people of Ecuador have elected a former coup l...
- When you take time to read a book or listen to mus...
- ......he believed that art affirms and sustains li...
- For more than 20 years, Antokoletz marched, clutch...
- Places by which Russia's ranking in the U.N.'s Hum...
- I blame the Vietnam War. That's safe enough; nobod...
- http://meltingobject.blogspot.com/http://www.where...
- Early this morning, during my clandestine coffee a...
- glimpses of another worldwhere people eat differen...
- glimpses of another world
- Even as Chilean courts have continued to pursue ac...
- Mexican Gen. Jos� Gallardo once seemed an unlikely...
- Todd Warren, a Sunday School teacher at Prairie Oa...
- the truly most astonishing astronomy photo I've ye...
- The struggle against detention certainly didn't en...
- "Why did you run from the police?" Chavez is heard...
- Mayor Ed Garza said Thursday that he hadn't spoken...
- Dr Zhou said the temptation to add a longer tail w...
- Previously, Herrin and Teplitz speculated that it ...
- Gloria Murillo�s one-acre farm in this central Col...
- One candidate screened by the White House was Will...
- Questions were mounting yesterday over the death o...
- women squat on the sidewalk using their bare hands...
- Earlier this year, in what appears to have been th...
- In early April, scientists reported that the early...
- And when those entries are laid end to end in a ti...
- As for the remaining six political parties, the Ge...
- ANTON MUSSERT AND THE DUTCH NAZI PARTY
- More than 280 women have been found dead in the Me...
- The vanity of the lilac's flowering Is in the brev...
- Liu Fang: The biggest challenge is to fully expres...
- The Nishikawa Ensemble is a chamber group that exp...
- {I saw Limbaugh on whatever talk show that was, an...
- Raising the Temperature: W Laser
- Dr. Tony Tether, DARPA (15-21 Oct): to Singapore t...
- Swaziland�s attorney general has been charged with...
- The chairman of the massive Rio Tinto mining compa...
- The decision followed three days of riots in the W...
- I have an agent now. This guy writes me down � the...
- a letter to a friend, for a few hours:____________...
- Iraqi flag
- as the good professor muttered "where is the camer...
- Thomas McGuane IV, blade smith
- MADRE�s Direct Relief Efforts MADRE purc...
- Human trafficking involves controlling and exploit...
- Robert(Birnbaum): Was your detailed description of...
- EC: Oh, he's not mad. Everyone else might be, but....
- Allen Ginsberg died a few days ago. You knew him, ...
- It's in the White House and Senate and judiciary. ...
- we win againtho it's always touch and goand even w...
- A Longview woman who sells sex toys has been charg...
- In 1961, under the last Eisenhower budget, there w...
- "First Thought, Best Thought" � Chogyam Trungpa, ...
- This man Calvino has been dead for some seventeen ...
- Israel will ask the United States for loan guarant...
-
▼
November
(320)