No, it's not anti-semitic
"Summers is right to voice concern about rising anti-semitism, and every progressive person ought to challenge anti-semitism vigorously wherever it occurs. It seems, though, that historically we have now reached a position in which Jews cannot legitimately be understood always and only as presumptive victims. Sometimes we surely are, but sometimes we surely are not. No political ethics can start from the assumption that Jews monopolise the position of victim. 'Victim' is a quickly transposable term: it can shift from minute to minute, from the Jew killed by suicide bombers on a bus to the Palestinian child killed by Israeli gunfire. The public sphere needs to be one in which both kinds of violence are challenged insistently and in the name of justice.
If we think that to criticise Israeli violence, or to call for economic pressure to be put on the Israeli state to change its policies, is to be 'effectively anti-semitic', we will fail to voice our opposition for fear of being named as part of an anti-semitic enterprise. No label could be worse for a Jew, who knows that, ethically and politically, the position with which it would be unbearable to identify is that of the anti-semite. The ethical framework within which most progressive Jews operate takes the form of the following question: will we be silent (and thereby collaborate with illegitimately violent power), or will we make our voices heard (and be counted among those who did what they could to stop that violence), even if speaking poses a risk? The current Jewish critique of Israel is often portrayed as insensitive to Jewish suffering, past as well as present, yet its ethic is based on the experience of suffering, in order that suffering might stop.
�
If we say that every time the word 'Israel' is spoken, the speaker really means 'Jews', then we have foreclosed in advance the possibility that the speaker really means 'Israel'. If, on the other hand, we distinguish between anti-semitism and forms of protest against the Israeli state (or right-wing settlers who sometimes act independently of the state), acknowledging that sometimes they do, disturbingly, work together, then we stand a chance of understanding that world Jewry does not see itself as one with Israel in its present form and practice, and that Jews in Israel do not necessarily see themselves as one with the state. In other words, the possibility of a substantive Jewish peace movement depends on our observing a productive and critical distance from the state of Israel (which can be coupled with a profound investment in its future course)."
�Judith Butler 21 August 2003
London Review of Books
________
Morning Prayers address
Lawrence H. Summers President of Harvard College
Cambridge September 17, 2002
________
Judith Butler resources here
and here
informant38
-
...But of these sophisms and elenchs of merchandise I skill not...
Milton, Areopagitica
Except he had found the
standing sea-rock that even this last
Temptation breaks on; quieter than death but lovelier; peace
that quiets the desire even of praising it.
Jeffers, Meditation On Saviors
-
12.9.03
Blog Archive
-
▼
2003
(1408)
-
▼
September
(201)
- proverbs that never were Adam and Eve asked of God...
- Voyager
- $50,000 per bed L. Paul Bremer, the American overs...
- He lived his life like a work of fine art He live...
- Kheshbon Nefesh The eve of the Jewish New Year is...
- Worried in Baghdad... What is particularly distur...
- The Adventures of Huckleberry Finn Of Mice and Me...
- Ω{So Dennett has it that the conscious mind is lik...
- Israeli pilots' refusal to carry out air strikes P...
- Pernicious Influence "God, what happens when Micro...
- soldier, soldier
- REVIEW GUIDE FOR FINAL EXAM: Freedom and Social Co...
- The Principles of Scientific Management The search...
- Edward Said More than any other Palestinian write...
- Life is looking pretty good Matthew Scott, 19, sai...
- ICE Operation Predator Operation Predator is a com...
- The Stench at EPA The Environmental Protection Ag...
- Caterpillar ...the largest grassroots Jewish peac...
- acidifying oceans If carbon dioxide emissions keep...
- Monsignor Otto Garcia " As antifreeze usually isn'...
- Tom Tomorrow 09.22.03 cartoon at salon
- Camp Five The new �Camp Five� will take three time...
- Venus possibly habitable for billions of years Thi...
- Kucinich: "I am the only candidate who will take t...
- "Forensic Video Decisions" Whitepaper "Forensic Vi...
- Ω{Just because I'm irritable from too much sleep f...
- The Small Drunk Hood ...the large teeth of accompl...
- comments at beatniksalad 09.22.03
- "...there are thousands of incidents of violence t...
- An Absolute Slaughter Every Night Robert Fisk: W...
- signs of life Physicists have created blobs of gas...
- They Lied and Many Soldiers Died George Bush won'...
- A Change of Viewpoint As a newly-promoted Army Se...
- Flavio and Alfredo Colombaioni The experience wit...
- Age 65 was established as being "elderly" by Otto ...
- "The laugh of big clowns" From the harlequin to th...
- Weren't any armadillos in the Lone Star state when...
- bling In a special focus on the Bushmen's plight...
- Lee Kyung Hae
- the hard-faced bitch with the peroxide hair. The ...
- China to help Europe develop GPS rival The US has ...
- mother, woman, human being In a short time the wo...
- Peace Now starts 'street campaign' with 6,000-str...
- Buddhist marathon monk completes seven-year run A ...
- Jonathan Schell links to "the indispensable" TomDi...
- Ashcroft derides Patriot Act critics "The fact is...
- what happens Union of Concerned Scientists retrofi...
- Calculating Google Google calculates.
- Forest makes up 70% of Russia's territory and span...
- 129 dead or missing and 4.6 trillion won ($3.94 bi...
- fair play Monkeys can spot a raw deal when they se...
- Reserve pilots to refuse 'liquidations' A group o...
- Ω{Kesey's response to somebody in the crowd jeerin...
- Survival
- "Elvis� as the GIs call him�has not left the build...
- more wordiness at Cassandra Pages Comments
- "Up in the air, Junior Bird-Men!" 09.17.03
- To assert that there is "a Jewish people" is to en...
- Memorandum on institutionalized racial discriminat...
- A Basic History of Zionism and its Relation to Ju...
- The Twin Towers and the Tower of Babel Part 1: Sle...
- Central Asia: Early travelers Part 2: Sven Hedin, ...
- Central Asia: Early travelers Part 1: Missions to...
- My Secret Life Exposed Ω{She says: "I have yet t...
- weighing in on words at �Cassandra pages 09. .03
- Maybe a better word... Ω{Great social work, as in...
- National Hurricane Center �Tropical Prediction Ce...
- Hurricane Isabel Approaches APOD 09.16.03
- Heart of darkness Two police officers in khaki tol...
- 15 girls from Zayoona Something you probably don't...
- It'll kill you -- wait, no it won't ... Donald J....
- Q. How can I tell whether a mirror is really a mir...
- Comment on Reproductive Ethics (CORE) � First hum...
- Breslin Surfs
- Why don't we have the answers to these questions? ...
- Soured on the sweet science The U.S. Congress shou...
- The Autumn of Little Caesar Meanwhile, Top Gun is ...
- Daily Reports from Cancun 09.14.03� This is a clea...
- Greeks 'borrowed Egyptian numbers' New research su...
- Juarez Women hold posters showing black crosses i...
- ...not for himself, but for the nation... Before ...
- From the Files of Mike Mailway The fax machine is ...
- Gunmen assassinate Iraqi police chief
- Fire kills scores in Saudi prison
- A bitter aftertaste the world makes too much coff...
- Dirty Tricks in the War on Terror ...serious alleg...
- Saudis Were Cleared to Fly Out of US on 9/11 Forme...
- $8.10 a day ...one that's been around for 22 years...
- In the Stars It's like an imaginary tale. Children...
- Blow to world economy as trade talks collapse ...t...
- No title
- Free Trade Is War After September 11, right-wing ...
- Five hundred miles and a world away Rice and maiz...
- "a sea of microwaves" Professor Leif Salford, Swed...
- Ω{I'm not following the so-called recall. But it b...
- The Soul of Capitalism: Opening Paths to a Moral E...
- Fascism In The Name Of Security An immigrant is li...
- Johnny Cash
- US killing of eight Iraqi police fuels anger in tr...
- The slaves of money - and our rebellion As if at w...
-
▼
September
(201)