A dismal thought experiment:
Maher, and a very large number of other apologists for Israel-no-matter-what, would say, although it would be hard to get them to say it clearly and openly, that the deaths of hundreds of innocent Lebanese women and children who have been killed in the "targeted" bombing of Lebanon are regrettable, but excusable, "collateral damage".
That the killing of women and children is a horrible thing, yes - and that outside the contextual boundaries of war it's one of the worst offenses in almost every legal and ethical system we have - but within the context of war it's merely regrettable, necessary, and forgivable against the necessities of defense.
But those same apologists for Israel-no-matter-what will insist that anti-Semitism is never forgivable, never necessary, never excusable, that it never takes place and never could take place in a context that makes the immoral moral, or excusable.
It is in that sense a worse crime than the killing of innocent women and children.
informant38
-
...But of these sophisms and elenchs of merchandise I skill not...
Milton, Areopagitica
Except he had found the
standing sea-rock that even this last
Temptation breaks on; quieter than death but lovelier; peace
that quiets the desire even of praising it.
Jeffers, Meditation On Saviors
-
3.8.06
Blog Archive
-
▼
2006
(705)
-
▼
August
(66)
- Most Bolivians don't wear ties.
- Alas, indeed, as well as gosh and my oh my:Alas fo...
- religion-news-religion and news
- disaster apartheid
- The Johnstown Calamity - Johnstown, Pa. Flood, 188...
- New Orleans Judge Slated to Release Prisoners Citi...
- Listen! Can you hear that? Off in the distance......
- what there is about mediocre reasoning that makes ...
- our closest relative is a friendly, sex-obsessed h...
- Middle East Children's Alliance-link from Gaza wit...
- When the baby turtles hatch, they will have to cra...
- UNEP Tunza International Children's Conferencefor ...
- Senator Hillary Stratton Clinton-Stratton
- an atmosphere of reconciliation
- they could mirror:A leftist candidate won the gove...
- Questions of fact that are threatening to wealth a...
- Without ethics man has no future.
- School children gave more to the Katrina relief ef...
- Kerry Ryan has died at the age of 35:She was the d...
- A staunch leftist, Morales was elected in Decembe...
- Witnesses said the missile struck the Reuters armo...
- as we address the challenges: A key House committe...
- The price of failure in this case:The United State...
- thousands of extra troops on the streets to wage t...
- There is no Iraqi army:There is no Iraqi armyMicha...
- Bill and Melinda Gates came off the political fenc...
- Ned Lamont is safely pro-Israel. The statement on ...
- a criminal group of terrorists:Count Folke Bernado...
- fruit juice and pears:Frankly, few if anyone invo...
- The most popular delivery device, the American-mad...
- Gaskin's hippie offshoots aid Katrina victims
- Vote-Buying Scheme Is Busted in Chiapas:Mexican po...
- good intentions and full speed ahead:"The West Af...
- A healthy insurance market is absolutely keyto a r...
- Do the crime, do the time:An influential federal p...
- Things! Come! Go! Alive! Better!:A US official has...
- four shirts and some pants:We had to drive around ...
- Litani River DebkaLitani River WikipediaLitani Ri...
- A last-minute blitzkrieg by Israeli troops and war...
- water under the bridge:Israel also signaledU.N. Se...
- one bite away: GRAND JUNCTION - Five more Mesa Cou...
- Severe, or Red:As always, we ask the American publ...
- along with other arms:If the shipment is approved,...
- Let's be clear, here:When Goldberg says "like an a...
- tugged that feather loose:But let's be clear: Lieb...
- sharper than what the public saw:...just 37 years ...
- We took our eye off the ball:The anti-Iraq War cha...
- a sensation around the world:Let's see here. Jim.Q...
- ...what they say is a limitless, low-risk reposito...
- exactly half the battle
- that close to where we are and beyond:As they prep...
- Along the way, we met an old woman who was crying ...
- "I'd like to boil my cat's tormentors."CJR
- in every Army division that operated in Vietnam
- Joe says:Mr. Lieberman also addressed criticism he...
- Monstrous:Once the police state vanishes, that ha...
- Some notes on anti-Semitism:I could speak to this ...
- It was a beautiful country:The government is incr...
- "The whole road is gone"
- a dab hand with the tuna:In the Shadow of the Moon...
- People I never knew existed until Molly Ivins told me
- A dismal thought experiment:Maher, and a very larg...
- forced to:According to Prime Minister Siniora, one...
- The Man of the Future is hard to see:U.S. lawmaker...
- He said that, while "a strong dollar is in our nat...
- Cuba (lots of broken links)LanskyCastro-Jeb Bush-O...
-
▼
August
(66)