In The Blank Slate, he notes "that there is a quasi-religious theory of human nature that is prevalent among pundits and intellectuals, which includes both empirical assumptions about how the mind works and a set of values that people hang on those assumptions. The theory has three parts".
One is the doctrine of "the blank slate": that we have no inherent talents or temperaments, because the mind is shaped completely by the environment�parenting, culture, and society.
"The second is "the noble savage": that evil motives are not inherent to people but come from corrupting social institutions.
The third is "the ghost in the machine", that the most important part of us is somehow independent of our biology, so that our ability to have experiences and make choices can't be explained by our physiological makeup and evolutionary history.
These three ideas are increasingly being challenged by the sciences of the mind, brain, genes, and evolution," he says, "but they are held as much for their moral and political uplift as for any empirical rationale. People think that these doctrines are preferable on moral grounds and that the alternative is forbidden territory that we should avoid at all costs".
Steven Pinker interviewed at Edge.org vis. his new book-
The Blank Slate: The Modern Denial of Human Nature
link via the consistently worthwhile girlhacker
informant38
-
...But of these sophisms and elenchs of merchandise I skill not...
Milton, Areopagitica
Except he had found the
standing sea-rock that even this last
Temptation breaks on; quieter than death but lovelier; peace
that quiets the desire even of praising it.
Jeffers, Meditation On Saviors
-
20.9.02
Blog Archive
-
▼
2002
(2976)
-
▼
September
(94)
- what was once considered to be the last of the Shi...
- A week ago in this column, after visiting Valenti ...
- George Walker, GW's great-grandfather, also set up...
- When you get down on yourself after you've done so...
- Fortunately, power has a shelf life. When the time...
- Voyage on, voyager. from a Sterling link
- Smart Mobs: The Next Social Revolution by Howard R...
- THE FINAL three minutes of hijacked United Flight ...
- As the unofficial spokesperson for the anti-global...
- According to the lawsuit, Brewer, 27, discovered t...
- here's the whole kit and caboodle, right on the mo...
- Eric Fischl's bronze, "Tumbling Woman," depicts a ...
- Authorities said the mother had left the store ang...
- ooo baba leba Helen Humes at mp3-blues.org
- Meditation Tip - by Murphy "Millions long for immo...
- The Crab Nebula Pulsar Shrugs
- Thousands of pilgrims in Thailand were visiting a ...
- Speed of light broken with basic lab kit 10:03 ...
- In The Blank Slate, he notes "that there is a quas...
- Q. Among men in their 20s, which sort is least lik...
- "The myth that the National Educational Associatio...
- Elron's zombies in the field: intimidation works. ...
- Q. What's Irish and stays out all night?A. Patio f...
- It's not hell until I'm on fire.
- If you bump into people (we tried it many times) i...
- An unusual triangle of light will be particularly ...
- dan gillmor links this most amusing page
- Seventy-one people, School of the Americas Watch t...
- He brightened. "I was just thinking of something. ...
- Caca rococo
- "I am so anxious," she said, after being coaxed fr...
- Media reports of threats Katie's received are inde...
- Carlisle then
- Jerusalem wheel
- In Chile, September 11 was marked by violent clash...
- PAUL CHODAS NEAR-EARTH OBJECT PROGRAM OFFICE, NASA...
- a formidable opponent
- about to be driven
- robotwisdom said moon trees and this is what that ...
- the looking glass is media-level journalism in qua...
- BAGHDAD (R) � Iraq's Deputy Prime Minister Tareq A...
- Twice in a two-week period, what authorities belie...
- Mr. Tom Tomorrow's got pretty much all anyone need...
- this is a photograph by Carolyn Forche's husband H...
- {Women for whom my love has never ceased to live a...
- Things We Lost in the Fire by Alisa Solomon
- What happened? AS THE United States mourn...
- {I've been feeling this push all day to write some...
- Under the Cloud We ran in all directions � to the ...
- wood's lot
- thrownaskew has songs of the week, and that zheuna...
- Jac Holzman's electric memoriesvia Markzilla, itse...
- toles comes through in the clinch
- in the other world our lives were very different, ...
- this is us, in an open not so much inclusive sense...
- "The ads say that doing drugs hinders the war on t...
- If you put your finger in ice water for 15 minutes...
- If you look at those matters, you will come to the...
- Tammany Hall
- dead broke
- son of Whole Earth uses tools and access for commo...
- more fun with Negroes { something larger that isn...
- stick people burning love
- Change since 1988 in the number of emergency rooms...
- current proposals to remove the government by depl...
- THE BUDDY HOLLY APARTMENT TAPES
- map of the world by ars electronica
- McGovern, for peaceand honesty.
- going to school{I was young ,too young for a lot o...
- kind of overproduced but refreshingly random searc...
- When the great teams came in sight at the head of ...
- Mexico's Supreme Court on Friday rejected challeng...
- "Clinton made a point of surrounding himself with ...
- Arab League chief Amr Musa rounded off a foreign m...
- why I read boiNgBoiNg, this is really cool progress
- Tom Tomorrow's rooftop view
- wreath of stars via robotwisdom(above)
- Tomaz Salamun (see also Mary Beth O'Connor) in Mas...
- If you still somehow manage to use the wrong one, ...
- diamonds in between the diamonds
- hats off to show biz
- Phoebe Thomas, eight-year-old Syrian girl, full-le...
- easy as pie
- 7 past
- Mickey's Jimmie
- aspects of what's good, or at least mighty ok, abo...
- velociraptor activismus
- links to the Hugo Award Nominees 2002 and Spider R...
- Mrs. Red Burroalso find Red Cloud's granddaughter
- MIT team probes arsenic and old lakes.The two rese...
- In the wake of the September 11 terrorist attack, ...
- In a speech in Maputo, Mozambique, delivered 12 ho...
- An Islamic high court in Nigeria upheld the death-...
- Victims in the case said they felt they had been d...
-
▼
September
(94)